Skip to Main content

  • Penny and Pearl's Bakeshop

Crafted bakery box from Penny & Pearl's with rustic charm

Penny and Pearl's Bakeshop 106 Fairfax Ave.

106 Fairfax Avenue, Louisville, KY
‌
‌
Cookie menu
Cookie cakes menu
Merchandise

Featured Items

  • Build Your Own Dozen

    A dozen cookies, each of the 12 flavor chosen by YOU!
    $29.50

  • Dozen chocolate chip

    $29.50

  • 12" cookie cake

    $35.00

Cookie menu

By the dozen

  • Dozen variety

    A dozen assorted cookies we select from our weekly menu.
    $29.50

  • Build Your Own Dozen

    A dozen cookies, each of the 12 flavor chosen by YOU!
    $29.50

  • Dozen chocolate chip

    $29.50

  • Dozen crème brûlée

    $29.50

  • Dozen birthday cake

    $29.50

  • Dozen snickerdoodle

    $29.50

  • Dozen sammies

    $33.00

Individual cookies

  • Chocolate chip

    $2.95

  • Crème brûlée

    $2.95

  • Brown butter snickerdoodle

    $2.95

  • Birthday cake

    $2.95

  • Chocolate crème brûlée

    $2.95

  • Lemon butter

    $2.95

  • Krispie rice bar

    $3.75

  • Chocolate chip sammie

    $3.25

  • Oatmeal vanilla bean sammie

    $3.25

Gluten Free

  • Half dozen GF chocolate chip

    $21.00

  • Dozen GF chocolate chip

    $35.00

Cookie cakes menu

Cookie cakes

***Please type words you would like written on your cookie cake under "Special Instructions."***

  • 10" cookie cake

    $30.00

  • 12" cookie cake

    $35.00

  • 10" double decker

    $60.00

  • 12" double decker

    $75.00

Merchandise

  • Logo tshirt

    $18.00

  • Logo mug

    $15.00

Build Your Own Dozen

$29.50

A dozen cookies, each of the 12 flavor chosen by YOU!

Customize your item

Individually wrapped

Required
Select 1

Tied with twine

Required
Select 1

Cookie Choice

Required
Select 12
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Penny and Pearl's Bakeshop Location and Hours

(502) 890-6004
106 Fairfax Avenue, Louisville, KY 40207
Open now • Closes at 6PM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement