Boxes
1/2
Welcome image


This week's menu:

(2/4-2/16)


Chocolate chip

Crème brûlée

Brown butter snickerdoodle

Cupid's confetti (bday cake)

Double chocolate V-Day M&M

Iced strawberry shortcake

Chocolate chip sammies

Red velvet sammies


Order Online

Freshly baked cookies. Weekly rotating flavors.


Penny and Pearl's Bakeshop started in our home kitchen in 2020, and thanks to our amazing customers we  quickly grew out of our small space. Now located in the heart of St. Matthews, our bakery makes fresh cookies and custom cookie cakes. Come in and see why everyone who walks in says "it smells SO good in here!"

Image


Whether you have a birthday, anniversary, or just a regular day...we'll be your go-to cookie cake shop.

Order your cookie cake here!